hikaymm
2 years ago1,000+ Views
Copyright Laws, Youtube & Common Sense
There's been a potential situation in the world of copyright and copyright claims building for quite a long time.
Is a video of me singing the words to a Beatles song violating copyright? Or does that fall under fair use?
Is it right that a video of me doing a dance cover (to the original song) of a popular Beyonce song could get taken down if her copyright management thought that it should?
I really have no idea, because copyright laws are unclear when it comes to fair use, and in most cases, people just give in to copy right holders rather than get caught up in a legal battle.

Recently, a court ruled against Universal re: copyright.

A Pennsylvania woman uploaded a video of her son dancing in her kitchen while one of Prince's songs played in the background (from her home stereo, not overlaid) back in 2007. Due to a claim by Universal Music, the video was taken down for six weeks. The woman challenged the claim, and it went back up, but she also filed against Universal for the trouble of it being down. Ultimately, she won the case and then, when Universal appealed, she won again.

How the EFF is Changing Things

The reason this case wasn't dropped was because the EFF was footing the bill and encouraging her (and others in her situation) to continue to follow through with claims like these.
"The Electronic Frontier Foundation is the leading nonprofit organization defending civil liberties in the digital world. Founded in 1990, EFF champions user privacy, free expression, and innovation through impact litigation, policy analysis, grassroots activism, and technology development. We work to ensure that rights and freedoms are enhanced and protected as our use of technology grows."
Thanks to the EFF, people are actually pushing back for reasonable fair use exceptions to copyrights. Usually, the problem isn't that courts are unwilling to rule on this. It's that pretty much every case gets settled out of court.

What's The Issue?

Basically, there are too many staffers out there working under the big music labels that are being too strict in their use of copyright laws. All they have to do is submit a claim to Youtube, and the video is down. While I understand that copyright infringement is a big deal and should be taken seriously, videos like this one --where the music is simply incidental and does not appear to have been picked specifically--should not be taken down.
I believe that copyright holders need to start properly considering fair use, and copyright laws need to be adjusted to provide more avenues for those who want to use and appreciate a song in their Youtube videos. Fine if they are not able to monetize the videos, but the take down system that is currently in place is out of line when it comes to many fair use videos!
6 Like
0 Share
10 comments
View more comments
@nicolejb I love that! As for whether or not it's plagiarism... my understanding is that plagiarism is defined by someone taking credit for another's work. I think with rickrolls, everyone knows that the person doing them isn't Rick Astley (at least, that's what we assume...) so I don't think it's plagiarism. It's not attributed, but it's sort of common knowledge. I could be off on that definition though
2 years ago·Reply
totally @shannonl5, I think because it takes on a new creative meaning, and it requires at least some skill to do!
2 years ago·Reply
@nicolejb sure! And I think the one you linked me to definitely counts as a reimagining. Even stuff that takes no skill (like just mash cutting two videos together, that's not difficult with today's technology), I think if it's expressing a new idea, or re-contextualizing the original media, it's not plagiarism. It's cashing in on the cultural currency the original media had, sure, but it's not really stealing. If anything, it's often adding to the conversation
2 years ago·Reply
@shannonl5 @nicolejb I love the way both of you think about it, it's very similar to how I feel about most copyright infringements. If you aren't just using the song to make a profit without crediting paying for it (like in a movie), and you're doing something new and creative with it I really think that's a big part of the music. Some artists can't understand that just like they used other people's work to learn, they should be willing to share theirs (to a reasonable extent), too.
2 years ago·Reply
and some of it is totally understandable @hikaymm! I think that artists get possessive over their work, but with a bit of education they can understand how it benefits them :)
2 years ago·Reply
6
10
Share