jeff4122
1,000+ Views

[Discussion] Clutch, or good?

I mentioned yesterday that I'd host a discussion about this key question in the sports world, and today I'm tackling it head on:

Would you rather have an amazing player who struggles in the clutch, or an average (or less amazing, at least) one who is known to have the ability to come up big in a dramatic moment?

For me, Peyton Manning has to be mentioned in this discussion.

His numbers paint the picture of far and away a top 5 QB of all time. To be honest, it's not difficult to argue that based on the numbers, he is the best quarterback to ever play the game. He leads the NFL in countless categories, both career-long and single-season statistics. He's won a Super Bowl and multiple MVP awards and has been a face of the NFL for years and years.
But there's just one thing. He isn't known for being clutch. While he won 1 Super Bowl, he has lost twice, including getting crushed by the Seahawks in 2014, when Peyton played terribly.

On the other end of this debate sits Tom Brady.

It's not to say that Brady's numbers are bad - they aren't.... like, at all, but they don't quite match Peyton's. On stats alone, Brady is still a top 5 QB ever, but it's tough to argue that he's the best ever based on numbers.
Brady has won 4 of the 6 Super Bowls that he's played in, displaying his amazing ability to come up big when it's all on the line. There's something intangible about Brady - when the game is on the line and he's got the ball, you just have tons of faith that he can come up with what is needed. I've been on the bad end of that all too many times as Jets fan. Brady has come back to beat the Jets countless times, and I know that even when the Patriots are down, as long as Brady is playing, they are not out.

So, I'm curious to know what the community thinks about this. Would you rather have a player who is unquestionably amazing, possibly the best of all time, but who has historically struggled to come up big?

Or are you willing to sacrifice some quality and talent for the ice that runs through the veins of a clutch player?

11 Comments
Suggested
Recent
I prefer consistency. Although it's great to be able to succeed in high pressure situations, truly great teams don't depend on just one player to succeed. The true formula for success starts with consistency at all positions. Aaron Rodgers and the Packers are the biggest example of a team that relies too much on their quarterback to save them from early game failures. There's a reason they haven't returned to the super bowl since 2010.
I think of a QB is good enough, like a Tom Brady or Peyton Manning, he won't have to be good in the clutch because the numbers are so good the big moments are minimal. That being said I'd rather go with a QB who is consistent enough to put up good numbers and keep the team in the game and when those big moments come up he can bring it home.
@EvanYannetti Hopefully that's not true....
@mchlyang it literally makes me wonder if he was cheating the other times he was in the Super Bowl
@EvanYannetti Hahaha no one will ever let that go
Cards you may also be interested in
NFL Dads Tackle Hair Styling In This Pantene Campaign.
Every year, major sponsors shell out some serious cash to grab our attention during the Super Bowl, by far the largest single sporting event of the year. They enlist A-List celebrities, bust out the CGI, and have the ability to transform a typical 30-second spot into a minute long movie of epic proportions. However, if there's one thing that these companies can learn from haircare brand Pantene this year, it's that turning on America's feels doesn't have to be that complicated - just bring in the adorableness of some NFL kids! Pantene's 'Dad-Do' Super Bowl campaign features a number of popular NFL fathers taking a stab at styling their daughters' hair with Pantene products. Like you could probably guess, they definitely struggle through it, but with some adorable encouragement from their daughters, the results are very much 'aww'-worthy. (My personal favorite is pictured above: DeAngelo Williams of the Pittsburgh Steelers versus his daughter Rhiya's braids and bows.) Benjamin Watson, tight end for the New Orleans Saints, displayed some pigtail game earning an impressed high five from his daughter, Grace. (He tried to argue that bigger hands make it hard for athletes to style hair, but he didn't do too bad for a first-timer!) The Dallas Cowboys' Jason Witten's adorable daughter Landry was SUPPOSED to get a braided ballerina bun, but let's just say there were some complications on the way. (Hey, if there's anything the Cowboys learned this season, it's that you can't win 'em all!) Click the video above for a look at the finished 30-second Super Bowl ad, or visit Pantene's official YouTube Channel to watch the full styling videos from each athlete. So how do you think they did? Was this concept just as adorable to you as it was to me? Let me know in the comments below and for more trending videos from across the web, follow my YouTube Nation collection!
I'm Ashamed of My Hometown
San Diego, get your shit together. Each year at the Padres stadium, Petco Park, the LGBT society in SD holds an event called "Out at the Park" that is meant to bring the community together for an evening of baseball. This year, Petco Park really, really screwed up. The San Diego Men's Gay Chorus was meant to sing the national anthem before the game to represent the LGBT community for this event. Their voices were never heard. The stadium let them take the field, and then as they were about to sing, a recorded female voice instead sang the anthem (which, if you've been to a Padres game, isn't something that happens - we always have live singing) The men had to walk off the field hearing people shouting profane, homophobic things at them. The Padres said it was a mistake, a technical error, a third party contractor, and that they were sorry. But that doesn't explain the other examples of mistreatment. Days prior to the game, the Padres organization told the performers that the chorus would have to pay for their tickets in order to sing. This is not something that happens, ever. If you perform the national anthem, you get to enter the park for free, DUH. Why did the Padres suddenly want this now? That would have cost the small organization thousands of dollars, and after dispute they were finally allowed in as performers. You can listen to their great voices here when they performed in 2015. It's a pity their voices weren't heard this year. Get it together Padres, you're a disappointment in baseball but don't be a disappointment to your entire community.
[CHALLENGE] Super Bowl 50!
Yes, the time has come. This is it. It's Super Bowl 50. Are you guys ready for this? We all know who's playing in it. So let the games begin! Here is the official challenge ---> Who will win this year's Super Bowl? The Denver Broncos or the Carolina Panthers? Here's a preview of Super Bowl 50! @ButterflyBlu @superiorsl @Starbell808 @InPlainSight @jokes @BEAUTYgirlARIEL @David19Flo23 @karencorchado @salahabdalla @Moose892 @BrookieyElba @SamuelRodriguez @ValerieAlissaPa @xitlalicordova1 @AndrewMaldonado @Jovi @Shippudenguy21 @AbdulrahmanSaad @trinityarcangel @thefeels @Link4TW @ChriSingularis @sanazsanaz @WilliamBrown @DannyMoses @ClaySharko @Ravenwing92 @FromBlue2U @TravisBeck @LemissaNicole @BossDominata @gatorchick96 @MatthewBoughton @MarcusJiles @BrandonMcNeil @MalikLawary @KyleBerke @manbungo2000 @DerekGumtow @havic @Straightshooter @PhilAnthony @Kirooken @yaakattackk @RodneyYoung @DreJones @JonathanKerns @bnzattoni @TravisManning @GalacticChakra @smothgreen @afxs @johnnolastname @ChristopherKenn @ChasePage @coreywriley91@MikeWolf @MrTenThirty @JasonNilsson @BrunoDutch @SherzTYC @krishntejanand @addri @ChrisStephens @AniBreo @GinnaL13 @VeronicaArtino @mishthi @andwas @TomasVasquez @oct6eg10 @NimishMathur @Sydsocquet @Darlin972 @GingerMJones @starli @kyleatekwana @ALEXCAMACHO @GabrielaAlvarez @strawhatblakley @VadimUsach @BenjiPhilip @Silver925 @Eduardo14 @AshfakEjaaz @brolyxxrborn @FernandaMontalv @coreywriley91 @EmanueleYagoda @DennieySnyder @TiffanyPerez @ShoMoPayton @m3179035411 @EvanYannetti @RaulGamboa @in4mtoxic006 @PaulFotiadis @sanRico @BlakeKaler @lilleonz @misterE @shagnasty360 @LeeroyEHutchins @Bobs @CheyenneHorton @TylerDurso @ChrisSantiago Sports fans, comment below with your predictions!
9
11
1