5,000+ Views

Why Don't Idol Groups Work In America?

In Japan and Korea, idols are a huge deal.

The fandoms surrounding idols and idol groups are massive, with a ton of merch, lingo, events, etc surrounding the entertainers.
So why isn't that happening in America?
The UK tried it out with One Direction and we have a few girl groups like Fifth Harmony and Little Mix, but for the most part the classic pop group ensemble faded away in the early 2000s.

Here are a few reasons why it might not work:

I'm not saying either opinion is correct - just stating how the general public views celebrities in America vs Korea/Japan. I'm not an expert on either so please share your opinions as well!

1. The Concept of Being An Idol

Sure, celebrities in the US know that they are role models, but do they really take this as their job?!
In Japan and Korea, a single slip up can mean public humiliation (such as when an AKB48 member had a boyfriend - she had to shave her head as an apology) while in America celebrities insist on their personal rights to do whatever they want.
In their opinion, just because you're a celebrity doesn't mean you aren't allowed a personal life. They should be able to be in the lime light but also have a lot of personal life that shouldn't be judged by the public,
In Japan/Korea, every aspect of an entertainers life is analyzed and people know that is just part of the job. You must be a model citizen at all times and any bad behaviour (whether its on or off camera) is bad for your company, your career, and your fans.

2. Company Loyalty

In America, we know the big companies like Warner, Sony, etc, but we rarely pay attention to what label each artist is on. And even if they're on the same label they don't really work together so its hard for fans to be loyal to one company.
The closest I think we can get to that is waaay back with Motown Records or more recently the bands that came out on Fueled By Ramen. Smaller hip hop labels still keep this group style too! We could actually see the connection the artists had on those labels and could support the label as well as the artists.
Now in Korea, we all know that companies are a big deal. YG Family, JYP, Cube, SM, etc. They do things together like concerts, Christmas songs, etc. We are able to anticipate the company's new project or collaboration. It's easier for the fans to get hyped over multiple groups at once.

3. Pre-Packaged

In America, bands are usually put together by the band members. Whether they start in a garage or they put up flyers to find members, it is the band that forms first, then the label that signs them.
In Korea and Japan however, we have a TON of trainees all hoping to be perfectly placed in a group. Think of the show Produce! Perfect example of prepackaging :) One Direction is an example of that happening where the boys were somewhat put together by a label, but musical and personality differences got in the way :/

4. Training

Idols train a LOT. Sure, in America entertainers practice, train, get vocal lessons, learn new instruments, get prepped for interviews etc but they are not forced to practice for 12 hours a day.
Living in dorms without cell phones or internet, being forced to learn languages, dances, public speaking, etc - its totally normal in the idol world. Because of this, idols should be pretty prepared for anything. I'm not so sure American entertainers would be up for this style of training.

Can you think of other reasons why the "idol" style of the music industry doesn't work in America?

There really are just so many cultural differences between the US and many countries in Asia. I am so used to the way our idols live that it is normal to me, but I can definitely see how those from the outside looking in here could not understand it. Sure US celebrities here have freedom, and that is what this country is about, but a lot of them end up going crazy because of this. Ex: Lindsey, Britney, Miley, you know the bunch.... I wonder how they would have turned out if their labels did indeed put at least some restrictions on them. But then again we all know how heartbreaking it is to see our idols suffering because of restrictions. It brings about a mindset there in which idols get hate for the littlest things! (EX: KAI!!!! Stop the hate please... ๐Ÿ˜ก)
The US is also very accepting of different body types, while many of our idols barely eat every day just so their weight can stay in the double-digits. I cannot see citizens here accepting that aspect of the idol lifestyle.
I agree with everything on the list plus the language difference. Everyone who watches the Kpop I show them always say "That was super awesome! I would watch more but it's in Korean. " If they took the time to look up the lyrics they would see the songs have beautiful lyrics! I don't understand why the language has to be a barrier in the first place, it should be about the music and the message and the presentation too, not just the language. If we only held importance for the lyrics in American songs, then the most important things to us would be twerking, drinking, and partying.
To be all honest, I think another reason would be because of fans. I mean, everyone on here, loves both their music and the music played here, but not everyone. I'm pretty sure an idols popularity would it be the same as in Korea or Japan. I mean, I pretty sure we all heard someone say something bad about KPOP. Like, they all look like girls when there boys, or the girls all are fake and have fake everything, so do you really think that's going to help an idol out? I mean, not everyone is going to love KPOP here, and most people in the US don't even know what it is or like it, so it's going to be pretty hard on an idol if they were in the US. We all love them and think their amazing, but not everyone does and that is most likely going to bring them down or hurt them, even through they have fans here. And let's face it, they have more support in Korea or Japan than here in the US. ๐Ÿ˜‘๐Ÿ˜‘๐Ÿ˜‘
What a lot of my friends complain about is how I'm able to listen to music that isn't in English. Which irritates me because people don't complain when they hear Spanish or when choirs sing in Latin. Another reason would be some of the strange concepts some idols perform. Like Orange Caramel. They have very... interesting music videos. Another reason I've heard people say they don't like about Korean and Japanese idols is that sometimes they can't tell genders apart. They find it weird how some girls look like boys and vice versa. Which I find completely absurd because that shouldn't matter.
Cards you may also be interested in
Get To Know: Treasure
Treasure are a 12 member boy group under YG. They all participated in YG Treasure Box. Members: [Hyunsuk] Full Name: Choi Hyun Suk Position: Leader, Rapper Birthday: April 21, 1999 (21 years old) - He's the oldest member. Nationality: Korean [Jihoon] Full Name: Park Ji Hoon Position: Leader, Vocalist (They have 2 leaders I believe, subject to change when more info is revealed as this info is relying on the fact that they were originally in two different sub-units) Birthday: March 14, 2000 (20 years old) Nationality: Korean [Yoshi] Full Name: Kanemoto Yoshinori Position: Rapper Birthday: May 15, 2000 (20 years old) Nationality: Japanese [Junkyu] Full Name: Kim Jun Kyu Position: Vocalist Birthday: September 9, 2000 (19 years old) Nationality: Korean [Mashiho] Full Name: Takata Mashiho Position: Vocalist Birthday: March 25, 2001 (19 years old) Nationality: Japanese [Jaehyuk] Full Name: Yoon Jae Hyuk Position: Vocalist, Rapper Birthday: July 23, 2001 (19 years old) Nationality: Korean [Asahi] Full Name: Hamada Asahi Position: Vocalist Birthday: August 20, 2001 (18 years old) - Will be 19 this month. Nationality: Japanese [Yedam] Full Name: Bang Ye Dam Position: Vocalist Birthday: May 7, 2002 (18 years old) Nationality: Korean [Doyoung] Full Name: Kim Do Young Position: Vocalist Birthday: December 4, 2003 (16 years old) Nationality: Korean [Haruto] Full Name: Watanabe Haruto Position: Rapper Birthday: April 5, 2004 (16 years old) Nationality: Japanese [Jeongwoo] Full Name: Park Jeong Woo Position: Vocalist Birthday: September 28, 2004 (15 years old) Nationality: Korean [Junghwan] Full Name: So Jung Hwan Position: Vocalist, Maknae Birthday: February 18, 2005 (15 years old) Nationality: Korean (I can't even imagine this because he was 14 while competing on YG Treasure Box. It's crazy to see someone so young!! I'm older than all of them (roughly 3 years older than Hyunsuk) and seeing Junghwan makes me feel old!) [Who is your bias?] [Mine are Yedam and Yoshi. Hyunsuk wrecks though!]