CrookedShadow
2 years ago500+ Views

Is It Weird For Guys To Sing Girl Group Songs?

Hello everyone!!

So this question has been gnawing at my mind for awhile. It first came to me when I was coming up with an idea for a fanfiction. And I've been extremely curious to see what you guys have to say about this.

Want to see what other questions I have for kpop fans? Then click the link!!

*Warning*

-This is NOT meant to be a sexist remark. I don't want anybody to think that I'm pulling out a feminist move or being a masculist. I want you guys to be completely open-minded when answering this and I DO NOT want to hear anyone bringing up that one gender is better than the other!!
-If this question offends you in anyway then I recommend just turning the other way and completely ignoring these cards. And if for some reason I am tagging you in them or if at any point these start to get offensive and you don't want to be tagged anymore than please message me and I'll be sure to remove you.
-DO NOT start to pull out hate comments or start to say rude things to someone based on their personal opinion. This is suppose to be a safe place and I intend to keep it that way. If I see any hate comments or any sort of bullying then I will delete that comment, and if too much hate is forming in the comments of these cards then I will end this series.
-If you have a problem with my cards then I recommend PM me and I'll be sure to talk with you about whatever you want to say to me.
Okay, so you all know that male kpop idols, as a form of fan service or cause they want to, will usually dance to girl group songs. Some of the most popular songs are like Ice Cream Cake by Red Velvet, Cheer Up by Twice, Up and Down by EXID, etc. And girl groups will usually do the same thing except with guy group dances.
But that's not my question. My question is: Do guys sing to girl group songs? I know that they will as a joke, but do they ever perform them or sing the entire song? I'm asking for both solos and groups. Like, have you ever seen all of BTS perform Up and Down by EXID, singing the entire song? Or has even Jungkook sang the entire song himself?
Come to think of it, I have heard Jungkook sing English covers that were originally by girls, and V has also done one himself. So that kind of answers my question, but I'm mainly asking if guys have done that with any kpop girl group songs?
I have tried searching these videos up, but I can't find anything like it. And, come to think of it, have girls ever sang to an entire boy group song either? When I first thought of this question I thought that I had seen girl groups singing guy covers but I'm not sure now. I mean, I've only mainly seen female fans singing their own covers of boy and girl groups songs, but only have seen guys singing to guy groups.
In my opinion, girls singing to guy songs is totally normal. If I had to perform a kpop song, singing, I would prefer singing a boy group song over a girl group song. My opinion though. So why is it such a weird thing for guys to sing to girl group songs? Is it just because of our society? That guys are suppose to have this masculine look to them? Then why is totally acceptable for them to dance to girl group dances?

What do you guys think?

Is it weird for guys to sing to girl groups, or do you think that should be a thing?

Would you be laughing the entire time if Got7 were to sing Shake It by Sistar, or would you be singing and dancing right along with them? That's all based on your guys' opinions.

Speakers of Kpop

(This is the taglist for my series known as "Can We Talk About Kpop?" If you would like to be added or removed from the taglist then either message me in the comments or send me a PM, and I'll be sure to follow up on that.)

The "Bruh" Peoplez

5 comments
Suggested
Recent
it's funny you bring up this question and made me realized I have not seen any clips of boy groups singing or dancing to an entire girl group song,(or vice versa) I personally find it fun and they show off a goofy side to them (and vice versa with the girls). the guys tend to do the parts of the dance that are either very popular from the group or a sexy part that shows off the body or makes it goofy. I guess I'm one of those people that like to see them having fun, but I also hope that they know we are laughing with them and not judging them.
I'm the same way. I want to see them having fun with the dances. I also hope that they know that we're having a good time watching them do these dances rather then them thinking that we're just making fun of them and judging them.
usually the full songs are preformed live but I don't think I've ever heard a boy group member sing an entire girl group song. I personally love it when groups sing each others' songs, girl or boy group doesn't matter, it really brightens up my day.
I think it is totally fine for the boy groups to sing and dance to girl groups. On the SBS Awards, they had a member from Monsta X, GOT7, and two other boy bands sing and dance to the complete song of Miss A, Good Girl, Bad Girl. I enjoy watching them. It shows how there are multiple talented.
I have no problem as long as it is something they enjoy. I would only protest those who are forced to do anything that makes them uncomfortable, by their fans and or agency.
I don't think I've seen them do a whole song either.. but I don't really look at that. I enjoy it when I see it mostly cause they look cute and embarrassed or they look like they enjoy it. It's fun, if they enjoy it (like jokwon for example, or at least that's how it looks) it's fun to watch.
Cards you may also be interested in
Jungkook Sundays!😍💜
Hello ARMY! Today is Jungkook Sundays! And I will be wrapping up mood boards theme for this week in the Bts Community! Tomorrow will be a new theme! ❤ ♡ ❤ ♡ Here is one of the mood boards I made I love the way it came out!❤ here are some more mood boards. *credit to the owner's of the mood boards* I hope you all enjoyed! See you all next time!❤ Jungkookie Crew: @Yugykookie97  @Jiminsnooder @DefSoul1994 @MelissaGarza  @VeronicaArtino @jungkookieeeee Kookie Taglist: @StephaniePoore @Mochiroon  @StefaniTre @Just2BLoved @rhonwytewa1234  @simpsonsamantha @arellano  @khrystelr  @jeonraeyoo  @Got7lover0228  @walkingintoyou *let me know if you want to be apart of the taglist* BTS ARMY TEAM: @Yugykookie97 @DefSoul1994 @MelissaGarza @Jiminsnooder @jungkookieeeee BANGTAN'S ARMY TAGLIST: @blessowmwago @echoxsoul @herreraletecia @HomegirlG @jiminiebae @Just2BLoved @kaylawalker929 @krissynormam @Mochiroon @Nyxxonn @QueenPandaBunny @rodrickagardne @simpsonsamantha @Shelbeigh19 @shellyfuentes70 @Starbell808 *let me know if you want to be apart of BANGTAN'S ARMY taglist* ~☆JJP Shake it Crew☆~ @DefSoul1994 @Yugykookie97 @Just2BeLoved K-Monsta Squad: @Yugykookie97 @BBxGD @lilbr0wneyes @DefSoul1994 @KpopGaby @MYAlpha @BangtanGirlOT12 Tag List: @cagonzales9696 @Jiminsnooder @MonieManhiM @cherriblossom17 @SimplyAwkward @Btsislife @jaselgalindo @emealia @saraortiz2002 @xsandos17 @VictoriaBossier @TaehyungKey @Sarahdarwish @kpopandkimchi @Emealia @terenailyn @MonAnnahiX @4dalientae @PrettieeEmm @kyokeo @KwonOfAkind @AnimeKpopLover @SugaOnTop  @QueenyCrossGene @MadAndrea @B1A4BTS5ever @zyxzj @Taehyungie @VKookie47 @NuXX @Baekyeol27 @DOislifeExoL @kpopbeat @BTSMicDrop @BulletproofV @PrincessUnicorn @luna1171 @LisetteZapata @herreravanessa9 @MadAndrea @AnimeKpopFreak @amandamuska @RandomName @aliendestina @mrsyookihyun @MaelstromVIP @Foxxyjinxx @Bangtanss @YessicaCardenas @JadeOwens @cns1391 @JJiBin @TheEnlightment @BlueMoon201 @QueenPandaBunny @emberreynemoll @LacyTanner @nyxxonn @SweetDuella @MmIlk @KihyunA @ARMY4Life @SerenaArthurs @Additional18 @jessicaclove  @olive07354  @YungStatin  @nickij @BTSLover14  @Mochiroon @LiyahBoon *Let me know if you want to be added or untagged from the taglist*
How to Make an Appropriate Card
Hello fam! I know we have many new ppl joining our Vingle family! I just wanted to make a card helping you all out. I've noticed some cards being submitted it inappropriate communities and awesome cards made that are only submitted to one community when it could be submitted to more! PLEASE DON'T GET OVERWHELMED...IT IS PRETTY EASY. Okay Quick Tips 1. Make sure you know community guidelines. So you can prevent your card from being rejected. 2. Title: Make sure your card has a title. This is the most important thing to allowing individuals see your content and know what your card is about. If it has mature content make sure to add +19. I SEE TOO MANY CARDS WITHOUT TITLES. 3. Adding pictures and or gifs that are relevant to your topic is always a plus!!! Now once a card is completely done all you have to do is submit it to relevant communities. If you create an EXO card these are possible communities that you could submit your card to EXO, Kpop, KpopBoyGroup, AsianMaleStars, KoreanStars. You do not have to just submit it to Kpop or just EXO. The more communities your card is published in the more ppl get to see it and the possibility of making new friends!!! I HOPE THIS HELPS!!! Ride or Die Peeps Taglist @lisablinkarmy @SolYLuna @szewwy @koalabear @SweetDuella @DefSoul1994 @blessowmwago @Starbell808 @Jiminsnooder @SarahHibbs @Yugykookie97 @WinKonVIP @simpsonsamantha @lrwc12 @Gladys21 @hyunjinnie @VeronicaArtino @Shanai88 @Mochiroon @jungkookieeeee @Blackrose139 @cathysanchez157 @KittyCat1998 @Kail916 @pandaqueen7 @MelissaGarza
President for SF9!
Hello Hello! Its SweetDuella here with some Happy news! Its time for a new term and I gathered a couple stray cmtys. . Hehe it be funny if one was stray kids but both are being well taken care of! I just got is SF9! Im excited to show some love for these guys. I plan on being diligent about showcasing each of the 9 guys! The group first performed in Japan on December 11, 2015. They first consisted of 11 members. Then In May 2016, they participated in the FNC Entertainment survival show "NEOZ Dance". At the end they won the show but had lost a few members bringing it down to 9 members, which kind of goes with the group name SF9. Since than they have had 6 Albums come out and lots of performances and concerts. Who are 9 members of SF9 • Inseong (Hangul: 인성, born July 12,1993) — main vocalist, dancer • Youngbin (영빈, born November 23, 1993) — leader, lead rapper, lead dancer Jaeyoon (재윤, born August 9, 1994) — lead vocalist, dancer • Dawon (다원, born July 24, 1995) — lead vocalist, rapper, dancer • Zuho (주호, born July 4, 1996) — main rapper, dancer • Rowoon (로운, born August 7, 1996) — main vocalist, visual, face of the group • Taeyang (태양, born February 28, 1997) — lead vocalist, main dancer] •Hwiyoung (휘영, born May 11, 1999) — rapper, dancer, vocalist] • Chani (찬희, born January 17, 2000)— rapper, main dancer, vocalist So a little introduction about me! Here are 3 things about myself! • Hi my name is Jenni! Im 29 yrs old •I have been hot and cold with SF9 ever since they came out • I am multifandom and have been on vingle for 3 and something years. I love that I got to know so many wonderful people in the kpop community through vingle! • I have a major soft spot for K Drama's and getting stuck in a time warp where I listen to kpop from previous Era's until Im ready for new music, So though I make it to the new songs and kpop groups, I dont always listen on repeat until they get filtered into my playlist. If Anyone wants to be tagged in the SF9 cmty cards just leave a comment! you shall be dubbed the Sensational fans! Also looking for Editors if anyone is interested! Keep in mind group chat will be in Kakao! fam tag! new updated list!  @SugaKookieV @StefaniTre  @SimplyAwkward @Starbell808 @SerenaArthurs @Sugasadamsapple @BabydollBre  @WinKonVIP    @Taekookimonster  @ESwee @Just2BLoved  @QueenPandaBunny   @Yugykookie97 @kpopandkimchi  @VKookie47 @MelissaGarza  @VeronicaArtino  @tinafalcon22 @tigerlily84 @Taekookimonster   @JaxomB  @divanicola05  @ynsamgwlk @rchacon19 @cns1391  @PolarStarr  @rocklvr @BTSARMYBOI @QueenyCrossGene @BTSMicdrop @Halsyeon @Maelyn
BTS President Community Intro!🤗👋🏻
Hello ARMY!! I'm back again with another intro card. Here in the intro card I will be telling you all a little bit about myself. I made 2 intro's yesterday for different communities that I am apart of. So some of you may or may not know who I by now. But here are some facts about me My name is Amber •I am 22 yrs old • I am the middle child •I got into kpop the beginning of my junior yr in High School. That was almost 7 or 8 yrs ago since I've been into kpop • My hobbies are reading, swimming, playing softball, watching kpop/kdramas and hanging out with my family & friends •I have 1 tattoo. It's in remembrance of my grandma that passed away on April 7th of 2017. I plan on getting more tattoos •I've been to 3 kpop concerts. ~1st concert was Got7 on July 1st, 2016 ~2nd concert was Monsta X on July 19th, 2017 ~3rd concert was BTS on September 15th, 2018 •My favorite NFL Team is the Houston Texans •My favorite MLB Team is the Houston Astros That is pretty much it. I'm sorry for all the repeated facts from different intro cards Click on the link below to read the Bts Community Guidelines!⤵️ https://vin.gl/p/2587031?asrc=copylink Click on the link below if you want to be apart of the "BANGTAN'S ARMY" taglist!⤵️ https://vin.gl/p/2587087?asrc=copylink I have so many things planned for the BTS Community! Pleade look forward to all the cards being made by me and my team. I am so happy to have these girl's on my team again! @DefSoul1994 @MelissaGarza & @Jiminsnooder . They do an amazing job making cards for you all❤ @jungkookieeeee is a new member on the team. She is apart of my team for Jungkook's community. She does an amazing job on her cards❤ I couldn't ask for a better team. These girl's are wonderful❤ Thank you so much girl's for being on my team! Love you girl's!❤ This week's theme we are doing a then v.s now them. So please look forward to that. @Defsoul1994 will be posting Monday's for RM & Wednesday's for Suga @jungkookieeeee will be posting Tuesday's for Jin @Jiminsnooder will be posting Thursday's for J-Hope & Saturday's for Taehyung @MelissaGarza will be posting Friday's for Jimin @Yugykookie97 (Me) I will be posting Saturday's for Jungkook Thank you everyone! Let's all have fun in the BTS community and share our love for our boy's!❤ *credit to the owners of the gifs & pics* Jungkookie Crew: @Yugykookie97  @Jiminsnooder @DefSoul1994 @MelissaGarza  @VeronicaArtino @jungkookieeeee Kookie Taglist: @StephaniePoore @Mochiroon  @StefaniTre @Just2BLoved @rhonwytewa1234  @simpsonsamantha @arellano  @khrystelr  @jeonraeyoo  @Got7lover0228  @walkingintoyou *let me know if you want to be apart of the taglist* BTS ARMY TEAM: @Yugykookie97 @DefSoul1994 @MelissaGarza @Jiminsnooder @jungkookieeeee BANGTAN'S ARMY TAGLIST: @blessowmwago @echoxsoul @herreraletecia @HomegirlG @jiminiebae @Just2BLoved @kaylawalker929 @krissynormam @Mochiroon @Nyxxonn @QueenPandaBunny @rodrickagardne @simpsonsamantha @Shelbeigh19 @shellyfuentes70 @Starbell808 *let me know if you want to be apart of BANGTAN'S ARMY taglist* ~☆JJP Shake it Crew☆~ @DefSoul1994 @Yugykookie97 @Just2BeLoved K-Monsta Squad: @Yugykookie97 @BBxGD @lilbr0wneyes @DefSoul1994 @KpopGaby @MYAlpha @BangtanGirlOT12 Tag List: @cagonzales9696 @Jiminsnooder @MonieManhiM @cherriblossom17 @SimplyAwkward @Btsislife @jaselgalindo @emealia @saraortiz2002 @xsandos17 @VictoriaBossier @TaehyungKey @Sarahdarwish @kpopandkimchi @Emealia @terenailyn @MonAnnahiX @4dalientae @PrettieeEmm @kyokeo @KwonOfAkind @AnimeKpopLover @SugaOnTop  @QueenyCrossGene @MadAndrea @B1A4BTS5ever @zyxzj @Taehyungie @VKookie47 @NuXX @Baekyeol27 @DOislifeExoL @kpopbeat @BTSMicDrop @BulletproofV @PrincessUnicorn @luna1171 @LisetteZapata @herreravanessa9 @MadAndrea @AnimeKpopFreak @amandamuska @RandomName @aliendestina @mrsyookihyun @MaelstromVIP @Foxxyjinxx @Bangtanss @YessicaCardenas @JadeOwens @cns1391 @JJiBin @TheEnlightment @BlueMoon201 @QueenPandaBunny @emberreynemoll @LacyTanner @nyxxonn @SweetDuella @MmIlk @KihyunA @ARMY4Life @SerenaArthurs @Additional18 @jessicaclove  @olive07354  @YungStatin  @nickij @BTSLover14  @Mochiroon @LiyahBoon *Let me know if you want to be added or untagged from the taglist*
Jimin Editor Community Intro!🙌🏻🗣
Hello ARMY!!!! It's me Yugykookie97!! And I am making an intro card! First I would like to thank @Jiminsnooder for letting me be apart of her team! She is going to be a great president for the Jimin community! Anyway's let's get on with my intro! ❤ ♡ ❤ ♡ My name is Amber! •I am the president of the Bts & Jungkook community! •I just turned 22 yrs old on March 17th! •I've been on vingle for about 4 years. I think •Bts is my all time favorite kpop group! •Jungkook is my UB but all of BTS wreck my bias list! •I am a multifandom! I will save the rest for my next intro card!❤ If you haven't looked at the guidelines for the Jimin community. Please ckick the link below⤵️ https://vin.gl/p/2587144?asrc=copylink If you are not apart of the Jimin Community. Please click the link below⤵️ https://vin.gl/i/Jimin?asrc=copylink *credit to the owners of the gifs & pic* If you want to be apart of "Jimin's Pinky Promise" taglist. Comment down below!❤ Christian ChimChim Squad: @Jiminsnooder @Yugykookie97 @DefSoul1994 Jimin’s Pinky Promise Taglist: *let me know if you want to be added to "Jimin's Pinky Promise" taglist* BTS ARMY TEAM: @Yugykookie97 @DefSoul1994 @MelissaGarza @Jiminsnooder @jungkookieeeee BANGTAN'S ARMY TAGLIST: @blessowmwago @echoxsoul @herreraletecia @HomegirlG @jiminiebae @Just2BLoved @kaylawalker929 @krissynormam @Mochiroon @Nyxxonn @QueenPandaBunny @rodrickagardne @simpsonsamantha @Shelbeigh19 @shellyfuentes70 @Starbell808 *let me know if you want to be apart of BANGTAN'S ARMY taglist* ~☆JJP Shake it Crew☆~ @DefSoul1994 @Yugykookie97 @Just2BeLoved K-Monsta Squad: @Yugykookie97 @BBxGD @lilbr0wneyes @DefSoul1994 @KpopGaby @MYAlpha @BangtanGirlOT12 Tag List: @cagonzales9696 @Jiminsnooder @MonieManhiM @cherriblossom17 @SimplyAwkward @Btsislife @jaselgalindo @emealia @saraortiz2002 @xsandos17 @VictoriaBossier @TaehyungKey @Sarahdarwish @kpopandkimchi @Emealia @terenailyn @MonAnnahiX @4dalientae @PrettieeEmm @kyokeo @KwonOfAkind @AnimeKpopLover @SugaOnTop  @QueenyCrossGene @MadAndrea @B1A4BTS5ever @zyxzj @Taehyungie @VKookie47 @NuXX @Baekyeol27 @DOislifeExoL @kpopbeat @BTSMicDrop @BulletproofV @PrincessUnicorn @luna1171 @LisetteZapata @herreravanessa9 @MadAndrea @AnimeKpopFreak @amandamuska @RandomName @aliendestina @mrsyookihyun @MaelstromVIP @Foxxyjinxx @Bangtanss @YessicaCardenas @JadeOwens @cns1391 @JJiBin @TheEnlightment @BlueMoon201 @QueenPandaBunny @emberreynemoll @LacyTanner @nyxxonn @SweetDuella @MmIlk @KihyunA @ARMY4Life @SerenaArthurs @Additional18 @jessicaclove  @olive07354  @YungStatin  @nickij @BTSLover14  @Mochiroon @LiyahBoon *Let me know if you want to be added or untagged from the taglist*
8
5
1