caricakes
1,000+ Views

Blurred Lines vs Marvin Gaye - Strike One

In one of the biggest trials ever over alleged song theft, this Thursday U.S. District Judge John Kronstadt denied Pharrell Williams and Robin Thicke's motion for summary judgment in a lawsuit that questions the origins of the mega-hit "Blurred Lines." The Pharrell and Thicke filed a lawsuit in September 2014 after receiving threats from Marvin Gaye's family, who contend the song is a knock-off of "Got to Give It Up." The Judge Kronstadt wrote that The Gaye family, "have made a sufficient showing that elements of 'Blurred Lines' may be substantially similar to protected, original elements of 'Got to Give It Up.' Defendants have identified these with particularity for purposes of analytic dissection." He also states that "the Gaye family has offered sufficient evidence to create triable issues about whether their 11-note signature phrase, four-note hook, four-bar bass line, 16-bar harmonic structure and four-note vocal melody are protectable expressions." This isn't the end for Pharrell or Thicke, because of complicated copyright laws, but the judges and Gaye family aren't letting this go without a good fight. Whether they base their claims off of sheet music or the technical details from the actual production, someone is going to be unhappy. A trial is currently scheduled for February 10, 2015. I provided a side by side comparison of the two songs so you can judge for yourself.
2 Comments
Suggested
Recent
First time I heard the song I felt the same way. I knew I had heard that song before and now the Gaye family reveals which song it was. I don't know if it was on purpose but for sure these things are related.
This entire case has been so complicated! I'll just be happy when its over!
Cards you may also be interested in
Update Jay Instagram
Que tal peeps! Are yall ready?! BO$$E$ Squad: @MarrickeJ33 @pandaqueenbee @KaeliShearer @dayashley11 @PriyaBala @BBxGD @VatcheeAfandi99 j-walkers: @elainarenea @MandyNoona @BBxGD @MarrickeJ33 @LocoforJiyong @dayashley11 @amobigbang @KaeliShearer @PriyaBala @VatcheeAfandi99 @passthesuga @sugaontop @twistedPuppy @nmeza29 @mrsyookiyun @firstladyofaomg @yaya12 @ViStorm @IsoldaPazo @lilbr0wneyes @amberg171997 @Zyxzj @Bwolfgirl @StefaniTre @dreemer13 @JordanShuler @JohnEvans @mitchix5 @maricela17mrn @TheEnlightment @Remysrose @Jaysbae13 @JasmineGregory @Nadi@elainarenea @MandyNoona @BBxGD @MarrickeJ33 @LocoforJiyong @dayashley11 @amobigbang @KaeliShearer @PriyaBala @VatcheeAfandi99 @passthesuga @sugaontop @twistedPuppy @nmeza29 @mrsyookiyun @firstladyofaomg @yaya12 @ViStorm @IsoldaPazo @lilbr0wneyes @amberg171997 @Zyxzj @Bwolfgirl @StefaniTre @dreemer13 @JordanShuler @JohnEvans @mitchix5 @maricela17mrn @TheEnlightment @Remysrose @Jaysbae13 @JasmineGregory @NadineEsquivel @MayraYanez @AnnaRodriguezm @lcr4562 @EliseB @ManduBum @kolai4 @ckienitz @SashaKmseoul @MayraYanez @AnnaRodriguezm @lcr4562 @EliseB @ManduBum @kolai4 @ckienitz @SashaKmseoul @MzDawson31508 Tagging mis amigos Ride or die peeps! @11erinmims @4dalientae A: @AaliyahNewbell @AdiaJasinskin @aliahwhbmida @AlexAckerman @AlexisRiver @aliciasalinas @AliciaStransky @AlmaRangel @AmandaOwnbey @amberg171997 @AmberRelynn @AmbieB @AnaP @Angelblue @AnnieGoodman @ArielaPicazo @ARMYStarlight @asdfghjkleyr @ashleyemmert @ashrose33 @awkwardjazzy @Airess95 @amandamuska @abiersack666 @AlloBaber @AgentLeo @alywoah @amobigbang @AshleiRyals @AdeleLynn @Animezkpopgirl @Amairani97 @al3ashalnaqbi B: @Badtz @B1A4BTS5ever @BAbrajan1 @baileykayleen @bambamisbae @bangtanella @Beckah1327 @BessanMerab @Bitterlimelight @blackirishawk @BluBear07 @BriannaN @brirodriguez412 @Britneygraham @BtsIsLife @BulletproofV @Byeoli @BekiKunstman @BAbrajan1 @B1A4BTS5ever @BlueBear07 @bbyitskatie @Baekyeol27 @B1A4BTS5ever @bambamisbae @BetseyBleau @bettytolliver @bambamisbae @bethanub @BreeMassey @Boinx @BiasKpop C: @CallMeMsDragon @CandaceJordan @CarleB @CarlaAcosta @CarlaPacheco @carolinaquito14 @CassidyRoush @CassieWarens @ccebox47 @ChauncySutton13 @ChavaBerry @ChelseaGarcia @chinabarrier16 @Chiqiang @Choijiah @christianliu @CocatolaOtaku @CrystalBlunt @ChristineO84 @CheyenneJesse @chinabarrier16 @ChelseaJay @ChristineO84 D: @Dabaesaplayer @DaisyPhun @DamarisCisneros @dancingdazzler @deefran @Defy24601 @DesireeChucklez @DestinaByrd @DestineeLiu @DreaG1518 @DonnaSearles @Destiny98 @daniimals @DesireeChucklez @Dabaesaplayer @DawanaMason @DarciAragon @DonnaSearles @DanaMichelle E: @EdithJang @EliseB @ElniWyatt @emilyanpham14 @enthropix @Ercurrent @ESwee @exobts947 @externallyeli @Elena166 @Ercurrent @Exoexo @Emealia @EXOAsf @elizabeth1234 F: @fleaisms @FrancescaV95BTS @funnelcakeboo @firstladyofaomg @fallchild @flxvour @firstladyofaomg @FromBlue2U G: @Gianlica @Gizzy2002 @gummydragon @glostick H: @hobisprincess @HunniNutFeelios @HyunnieKim @ILikeHisFace123 @HayleyYates @Helixx @hayoungforever @heidichiesa I: @InnocentiaKishi @IsoldaPazo @iraVVIP @imawhalien52 J: @JadeNarine @JadeOwens @jaidemae @Jasminep96 @JasmineWilliams @JasminMartinez @JasminPerez @JayRaider @jazgaara33 @JelliBelli111 @jessicacheung97 @JessicaFigueroa @jimin21abs @jiminsabs @JinsPrincess86 @Jiyongixoxo @justcallmekyki @JazzyJazJaz @JohnHomampha @JustinaNguyen @JaclynGuajardo @JohnEvans @jojojordy2324 @JaeneashaJones @JasmineGregory K: @KAddict @kanatm @kandle779 @KarenGuerra93 @KarenHer @KatMejia @KatelynSummerso @KarlythePanda66 @KaylaStokes @KellyOConnor @Kelsiumm @Keniaaxox @KeylaMoreno @kgutierrez @KhouYang @Kieuseru @KimHeecha @kmeier230 @kpopbunny9 @kpopandkimchi @KPOPER1 @KPopFandom @KpopGaby @Kpoplover20 @Kpossible4250 @krin @KrystaDaricek @KwonOfAKind @Kyokeo @KpopQueenaBee @KDramaKPop1015 @Kyokeo @kolai4 @kimnam94 @KokoroNoTakara @Kayto4 L: @lashonda0917 @LaurenStrayhorn @leelee12 @LenaBlackRose @lennykpop @LexTay327 @Lexxcisco @Ligaya @LilySilver @liannet27 @lisbt92 @Lizzeh @loftonc16 @LlamaBaozi577 @LolImbetter09 @luna1171 @LisetteZapata @LauraEspinoza M: @MaatiCasanova @Maddie27 @maddiedo @MandyNoona @MariahMaes @MaricelvaRomero @Meeshell @megancurrent9 @MelinaHernandez @MelissaGarza @merryjayne13 @MichelleIbarra @Mightmuffin @MinDeji @minimonkey07 @Minnieluvs @MirandaStephens @mirandazamira @MischiefK1ng @MistressSiren @moonchild03 @MorganElisabeth @MsLoyalHeart @mszmarclyne93 @musicmofo @myylifeisnow @MyriamMadla98 @MZDawson31508 @MichelleRosa @MadAndrea @MyaIsNotSexy @Maddie27 @Marilovexoxo @Mercii @milcalopez963 @MissMinYoongi @mitchix5 @Mavis2478 @MoraLesley @mrsax2018 @matty0203 @MaelstromVIP N: @NaughTae @NelyLovo @nenegrint14 @nerdy3000 @ninjamidori O: @Onenonlybovie @OnLarrysCloud @ot12exodus02 P: @pharmgirlerin @Pickles440 @pkhyeri @PrincessUnicorn @poojas @Purplicious @PrettieeEmm @ParkHwaYoung @parktaemi @PandaSoapy @pandaqueenbee @punkpandabear Q: @QueenLele R: @raenel @rapmonsterous20 @resavalencia @reyestiny93 @Rhia @rosajlm2 @roseeoh @Roxy1903 @Rina143 @RihannaTiaMay @RainaC3 @reyestiny93 @ravenrave95 @requiem101 @RKA916 S: @SamanthaRae19 @sarahdarwish @SarahVanDorn @sarangseoltang @SarangRavi @saraortiz2002 @Shadyllamas @shelbiisonfire @ShimJooKyung @ShinoYuki @SierraBecerra @SilentPianist @Simba14 @SkyRollins @solodaywithB1A4 @squishyseokjin @staceyholley @Stefany17 @StephaniePoore @sugakookie @sugasweetness @SunnaWalo @SunshineChang @SusiBosshammer @SimplyAwkward @StefaniTre @stevieq @shantalcamara @staceyholley @SugalessJams @solodaywithB1A4 @SaiT @StephanieDuong @SarahVanDorn @ShimJooKyung @SamanthaRae19 @Sinon1488 @SarahHm11 @shisuschrist @ScarletMermaid @SugaOnTop @SugaMint @shelbyhusband @senia @StefaniTre T: @Taehyungie @TaehyungKey @Taisa @TeaeraHarrell @terenailyn @thatoneoutcast @Ticasensei @tiffany1922 @tinaechle @TLeahEdwards @ToppDogg @torchix @TracyLynnn @TaehyungV @terenailyn @Taehyungkey @taetaebaozi @twistedPuppy @Tamaki1618 @Tigerlily84 @tayunnie @twistedPuppy @TessStevens @twistedlove @taetaebaozi @Tabili @twistedlove U: @UnnieCakesAli V: @Vay754 @VeronicaArtino @VioletaDelRio @ViStorm @viviano6 @Vixxstarlight1 @VKookie47 @vlargos @vyntnguyen24 @VIPforever123 @Vkookie47 @VixenViVi @VIPFreak2NE1 @VatcheeAfandi99 W: @Winx9119 X: @XergaB20 @XionHeart @Xoxojessica12 @xsandos17 @xroyalreisx Y: @yaya12 @yewookyu @YeniGonzalez @yeniyx23 @YessicaCardenas Z: @zzzdonk DON'T COPY MY TAGLIST
Minhyuk Hurt Again?
Multiple fans at a fan meet in Manila, as the video was posted by a girl there, a fan reportedly asked him if his leg was ok due to how he looked in the first couple of songs, he responded saying that he was fine. But also seen in the video at the end he bowed at his part because he knew it was obvious he in fact did hurt his right knee and was messing up during the dances. It is very painful to watch, seeing how much it hurts him. GET BETTER SOON MINHYUKIE! <3 ~ TAGGING MY YEOLIES!! ♡~ @Chace @MadAndrea@JustinaNguyen @jazgaara33 @MrsBangYongguk @Badtz @ScarletMermaid @PrettieeEmm @punkpandabear @LaurenStrayhorn @SusiBosshammer @JamiMilsap @VeronicaArtino @ElenaP16 @KellyOConnor @Kyokeo @Sankeerthana @EmilyCayetano @shellyfuentes70 @MBLAQSA @P1B2Bear @Kpopfangirl15 @Bitterlimelight @jojojordy2324 @Rawr21 @Juliag13 @KaiJae @ArmyofKookie @AaliyahNewbell @resavalencia @SugaOnTop @Sammie99522 @minimanim3 @Defy24601 @StefaniTre @SugaMint @DesireeChucklez @sarahdarwish @VatcheeAfandi99 @EliseB @VKookie47 @TiffanyBibian @taetaebaozi @RebeccaLondon @Katherina2078 @AimeeH @KpopQueen1 @KatelynSummerso @Kylie88 @CrystalGuerra @QueenLele @Minnieluvs @kimnam94 @CamrynCherry @Izzy987 @faith92 @TaehyungV @BetseyBleau @nenegrint14 @Lesliesoo @ninjamidori @Ihiranthom13 @MelissaGarza @DesireeChucklez @Maddie27 @PrettieEmm @MelinaHernandez @abby177 @PandaSoapy @DayzC @DawanaMason @Daniimals @jeonjungkook8 @AaliyahNewbell @IsoldaPazo @xoxorittie @LysetteMartinez @KittyKpop @motionlessmetal @herreravenessa9 @rosajlm2 @ChoHee1 @MaddieRudicil @michievip @kanatm @AlysaNguyen @Katmejia @Choijiah @GabyWilliams @jessicaacosta9 @Tamsinskye @TiffanyBibian @KpopQueenaBee @TracyLynnn @AlisonNichole @KpopandKdrama @emily1478 @Vay754 @alishap @CrystalGuerra @xojuliettexox @michix5 @amandamuska @StephaniePoore @SugaKookieV @KatelynSummerso @aliciazitting88 @Joshuahoseok @BtsIsLife @Chrissy2009 @mycreativename @jungkookie18 @ArielaPicazo @IDK2018 @MalinaAhmed @BaroMaiden @imiebegay14 @Taisa @kcastaneda170 @ChrystalA @DestinaByrd @BriannaN @taeyumme @MarrickeJ33 @ShailaZaman @RainaC3 @Gaarita100 @CamrynCherry @BonnieDomo @JessicaSchnipke @Minsuggie @karinamiranda81 @MomoChamie @Ilikepancakes @YessicaCardenas @Bmelc @callmeguena @JessicaVang @LydiaYan @toitlepark @lunastormnoona @Jupiterchan @BreeMassey @Vixxstarlight1 @katcollins02 @Zhac16 @TaehyungV @93yogurt @Kat711 @DejaunaSiders @EmilyGardner @ezzygomez24 @MaraWhite @Defy24601 @MahelySandoval @TrishaLee727 @InnocentiaKishi @SophieNguyen @MorleeCorielus @ruthmilian89 @XergaB20 @TLeahEdwards @EstelaLopez @KDluvR1999 @KatieRussell @AliciaJaneth @rochellelove12 @EvilGenius @JessicaFigueroa @TesneemElAlami @kpopdeluxegirl @JuviaJongdae @Jeshaki @yehetmyohorat99 @nathalyalamo298 @jessicacheung97 @Norma1004 @luyawn @CheyanneLindsey @sherrysahar @DanaAmoi @StarishaRichard @jazgaara33 @ButterflyBlu @karinajune1017 @lizbethV @JasmineWilliams @LilianaGD @deefran @agirlwholovesV @lashonda0917 @Kyokeo @KierstinAndrews @terenailyn @BAbrajan1 @Rebecca22 @GerciaFlores @KrystaDericek @megancurrent9 @roseeoh @musicundefined9 @MaryNtanga @sarahdarwish @MadAndrea @Konnor @externallyeli @LizaNightshade @SugaKookies @lashonda0917 @ArmyVIPKayla @elainarenea @2Jaebam @amobts @kpopandkimchi @NicoleJolly @bapastro @parktaemi
Jay Park & Ugly Duck Teasers
Que tal peeps! I know we are waiting for this new video and some have b already posted the teasers. I'm just making a card with them on one card. This ish will be hot! Teaser 1 Teaser 2 Teaser 3 Tagging mis amigos @11erinmims @4dalientae A: @AaliyahNewbell @AdiaJasinskin @aliahwhbmida @AlexAckerman @AlexisRiver @aliciasalinas @AliciaStransky @AlmaRangel @AmandaOwnbey @amberg171997 @AmberRelynn @AmbieB @AnaP @Angelblue @AnnieGoodman @ArielaPicazo @ARMYStarlight @asdfghjkleyr @ashleyemmert @ashrose33 @awkwardjazzy @Airess95 @amandamuska @abiersack666 @AlloBaber @AgentLeo @alywoah B: @Badtz @B1A4BTS5ever @BAbrajan1 @baileykayleen @bambamisbae @bangtanella @Beckah1327 @BessanMerab @Bitterlimelight @blackirishawk @BluBear07 @BriannaN @brirodriguez412 @Britneygraham @BtsIsLife @BulletproofV @Byeoli @BekiKunstman @BAbrajan1 @B1A4BTS5ever @BlueBear07 @bbyitskatie @Baekyeol27 @B1A4BTS5ever @bambamisbae @BetseyBleau @bettytolliver @bambamisbae @bethanub @BreeMassey C: @CallMeMsDragon @CandaceJordan @CarleB @CarlaAcosta @CarlaPacheco @carolinaquito14 @CassidyRoush @CassieWarens @ccebox47 @ChauncySutton13 @ChavaBerry @ChelseaGarcia @chinabarrier16 @Chiqiang @Choijiah @christianliu @CocatolaOtaku @CrystalBlunt @ChristineO84 @CheyenneJesse @chinabarrier16 @ChelseaJay @ChristineO84 D: @Dabaesaplayer @DaisyPhun @DamarisCisneros @dancingdazzler @deefran @Defy24601 @DesireeChucklez @DestinaByrd @DestineeLiu @DreaG1518 @DonnaSearles @Destiny98 @daniimals @DesireeChucklez @Dabaesaplayer @DawanaMason @DarciAragon @DonnaSearles E: @EdithJang @EliseB @ElniWyatt @emilyanpham14 @enthropix @Ercurrent @ESwee @exobts947 @externallyeli @Elena166 @Ercurrent @Exoexo @Emealia F: @fleaisms @FrancescaV95BTS @funnelcakeboo @firstladyofaomg @fallchild @flxvour @firstladyofaomg G: @Gianlica @Gizzy2002 @gummydragon @glostick H: @hobisprincess @HunniNutFeelios @HyunnieKim @ILikeHisFace123 @HayleyYates @Helixx I: @InnocentiaKishi @IsoldaPazo J: @JadeNarine @JadeOwens @jaidemae @Jasminep96 @JasmineWilliams @JasminMartinez @JasminPerez @JayRaider @jazgaara33 @JelliBelli111 @jessicacheung97 @JessicaFigueroa @jimin21abs @jiminsabs @JinsPrincess86 @Jiyongixoxo @justcallmekyki @JazzyJazJaz @JohnHomampha @JustinaNguyen @JaclynGuajardo @JohnEvans @jojojordy2324 @jordanhamilton K: @KAddict @kanatm @kandle779 @KarenGuerra93 @KarenHer @KatMejia @KatelynSummerso @KarlythePanda66 @KaylaStokes @KellyOConnor @Kelsiumm @Keniaaxox @KeylaMoreno @kgutierrez @KhouYang @Kieuseru @KimHeecha @kmeier230 @kpopbunny9 @kpopandkimchi @KPOPER1 @KPopFandom @KpopGaby @Kpoplover20 @Kpossible4250 @krin @KrystaDaricek @KwonOfAKind @Kyokeo @KpopQueenaBee @KDramaKPop1015 @Kyokeo @kolai4 @kimnam94 @KokoroNoTakara L: @lashonda0917 @LaurenStrayhorn @leelee12 @LenaBlackRose @lennykpop @LexTay327 @Lexxcisco @Ligaya @LilySilver @liannet27 @lisbt92 @Lizzeh @loftonc16 @LlamaBaozi577 @LolImbetter09 @luna1171 @LisetteZapata @LauraEspinoza M: @MaatiCasanova @Maddie27 @maddiedo @MandyNoona @MariahMaes @MaricelvaRomero @Meeshell @megancurrent9 @MelinaHernandez @MelissaGarza @merryjayne13 @MichelleIbarra @Mightmuffin @MinDeji @minimonkey07 @Minnieluvs @MirandaStephens @mirandazamira @MischiefK1ng @MistressSiren @moonchild03 @MorganElisabeth @MsLoyalHeart @mszmarclyne93 @musicmofo @myylifeisnow @MyriamMadla98 @MZDawson31508 @MichelleRosa @MadAndrea @MyaIsNotSexy @Maddie27 @Marilovexoxo @Mercii @milcalopez963 N: @NaughTae @NelyLovo @nenegrint14 @nerdy3000 @ninjamidori O: @obiterdictum @Onenonlybovie @OnLarrysCloud P: @P1B2Bear @pharmgirlerin @Pickles440 @pkhyeri @PrincessUnicorn @poojas @Purplicious @PrettieeEmm @ParkHwaYoung @parktaemi @PandaSoapy @pandaqueenbee Q: @QueenLele R: @raenel @rapmonsterous20 @resavalencia @reyestiny93 @Rhia @rosajlm2 @roseeoh @Roxy1903 @Rina143 @RihannaTiaMay @RainaC3 @reyestiny93 @ravenrave95 S: @SamanthaRae19 @sarahdarwish @SarahVanDorn @sarangseoltang @SarangRavi @saraortiz2002 @Shadyllamas @shelbiisonfire @ShimJooKyung @ShinoYuki @SierraBecerra @SilentPianist @Simba14 @SkyRollins @solodaywithB1A4 @squishyseokjin @staceyholley @Stefany17 @StephaniePoore @sugakookie @sugasweetness @SunnaWalo @SunshineChang @SusiBosshammer @swarrier16 @SimplyAwkward @StefaniTre @senia @stevieq @shantalcamara @staceyholley @SugalessJams @solodaywithB1A4 @SaiT @StephanieDuong @SarahVanDorn @ShimJooKyung @SamanthaRae19 @Sinon1488 @SarahHm11 @shisuschrist @ScarletMermaid @SugaOnTop @SugaMint @sherrysahar T: @Taehyungie @TaehyungKey @Taisa @TeaeraHarrell @terenailyn @thatoneoutcast @Ticasensei @tiffany1922 @TiffanyBibian @tinaechle @TLeahEdwards @ToppDogg @torchix @TracyLynnn @TaehyungV @terenailyn @Taehyungkey @taetaebaozi @twistedPuppy @Tamaki1618 @Tigerlily84 @tayunnie @twistedPuppy @TessStevens U: @UnnieCakesAli V: @Vay754 @VeronicaArtino @VioletaDelRio @ViStorm @viviano6 @Vixxstarlight1 @VKookie47 @vlargos @vyntnguyen24 @VIPforever123 @Vkookie47 @VixenViVi @VIPFreak2NE1 X: @XergaB20 @XionHeart @Xoxojessica12 @xsandos17 @xroyalreisx Y: @yaya12 @yewookyu @YeniGonzalez J-walkers @elainarenea @MandyNoona @BBxGD @MarrickeJ33 @LocoforJiyong @dayashley11 @amobigbang @KaeliShearer @PriyaBala @VatcheeAfandi99 @passthesuga @sugaontop @twistedPuppy @nmeza29 @mrsyookiyun @firstladyofaomg @yaya12 @ViStorm @IsoldaPazo @lilbr0wneyes @amberg171997 @Zyxzj @Bwolfgirl @StefaniTre @dreemer13 @JordanShuler @JohnEvans @mitchix5 @maricela17mrn @TheEnlightment @Remysrose @Jaysbae13 @JasmineGregory @NadineEsquivel @MayraYanez @AnnaRodriguezm @lcr4562 @EliseB @ManduBum