Let your little bakers make their own pumpkin pie this year! What you'll need: Small paper plate Brown and orange paint Paint brush Cotton ball Pumpkin pie spice How to make your Pumpkin Pie Paint the inside of the paper plate orange. Paint the outside rim of the paper plate brown. While the paint on the plate is still wet, sprinkle some pumpkin pie spice onto the plate. Add a cotton ball to the middle of the paper plate (the paint will glue it into place).