yourinsomnia
5,000+ Views

Nice Guy Drama Review Final Rating 85%

Drama Title: 착한남자 English Title: Nice Guy/The Innocent Man Episodes: 20 Channel: KBS2 Genre: melodrama, romance Cast: Song Joong Ki, Moon Chae Won, Park Si Yeon Description: Ma Ru would have done anything for Jae Hee, the love of his life. But she uses his love to let him take the blame for a murder she committed, then marries an older, rich man to escape her life of poverty. Devastated by her betrayal, Ma Ru is a changed man. Once a promising medical student, he now works as a bartender and gigolo, using women to get what he wants. When he meets the daughter of Jae Hee’s new husband, Eun Gi, he realizes he can use her to bring down the first love who betrayed him. (source: viki.net) Tropes: wronged hero, chaebol heirs and company takeovers, amnesia, noble idiocy Review: As I was thinking of tropes to include in this review, I began to come to terms with the fact that despite donning the mask of a classic melodrama Nice Guy managed to eschew, at least partially, of number of significant kdrama tropes and clichés. Take for example one of the most popular Kdrama tropes out there – evil/meddling parents. Did Nice Guy have a bit of that? Eun Gi’s father wasn’t exactly a sweetheart and I would even go as far as to say that he was the one overbearing aspect of her life that turned her into a closed off, emotionally stunted woman that she was in the beginning and yet… listing that trope doesn’t feel quite right either. Despite the importance of Eun Gi’s upbringing and then later on the significance of Eun Gi’s behavior towards her dad, he is never demonized, nor even given enough narrative care in general, to be anything but an auxiliary and almost perfunctory plot device. Like many other plot devices in Nice Guy such as first love, betrayal, evil parents, meddling secondary girl, amnesia and etc, it is merely half of a trope, only there to help set the conflicts in motion and hold the skeleton of the story, but has no place neither in the story’s material facet nor beyond it, in the story’s heart of hearts – meaning and intent. For many of us who were led to believe by the promos that Nice Guy will somehow be a revenge story it might have been disorienting to discover that revenge was not only irrelevant in the context of the greater message that writer Lee Huyn Hee strove to convey but it was NOT going to take place at all. Even the first arc of story does a great job of shrouding Maru motivations so that we are left wondering and attributing meaning and value to things that may not necessarily be there. Ultimately, Nice Guy is not a story of revenge, or even severely complicated human relationships, but a story of simple sentiment, a pure and innocent idea of redemption and healing. In the words of ever-so-wise Mr. X, when he alludes to the symbolism of the hand ticking backwards from the opening’s clock – “So the ticking clock becomes a personal and desperate struggle by the characters to remove those frail masks they were forced by the circumstances to wear, but also a journey of healing – feeling which manifests itself at the end.” I highly recommend to read the full article over at his blog http://vaultofdoom.wordpress.com. Whether it is our thwarted expectations or the frail skeletons of Lee Huyn Hee’s writing that prevent Nice Guy from achieving perfection or even excellence, and as consequence losing the ability to affect some viewers in the process, in the end, Nice Guy has enough positive attributes to be a standout drama. Watch it for sublime acting. For the perfection that is Moon Chae Won and Song Joong Ki’s chemistry. For the quite, understated dialogue and the charged interactions between them. Watch this drama for a number of great characters such as Jae Hee, who admittedly got unbearably loathsome at some point but never two dimensional or boring, and Joon Ha, who didn’t get nearly enough of the story’s share but was nevertheless compelling in his care for Eun Gi. Watch it to hear “If You Are Going To San Francisco” several times; if that song needs any extra nostalgia added for you. Watch it for the gorgeousness of the cinematography and the care that went into every single scene and shot. Watch because it is arguably the most prominent (melo)drama of the year and because it will likely become iconic in the years to come. Highs: acting, cinematography, production, dialogue Lows: unfilled potential of some of the side characters, ending feels disconnected from the rest of the drama, will leave some viewers cold My bias: my bias for this one is dysfunction and melodrama which truthfully I didn’t get enough of. Or rather it wasn’t as satisfying as I have anticipated. Final rating: 85%
Comment
Suggested
Recent
Cards you may also be interested in
If BTS Were in Boys Over Flowers
Now, I think there are a lot of things wrong with the plot of BoF (mainly the boys treat Jan-di like crap) but its still funto imagine it as a less problematic drama. Here's who I'd cast! Gu Jun Pyo - Suga The leader of the F4 and heir to the Shinhwa Group, one of the biggest companies in South Korea. He is hot-tempered and believes that there is nothing that money can't buy. Though he's unable to express his feelings, deep down, he has a heart of gold. He torments Jan-di after she stands up to his bullying ways, but ends up falling in love with her and will do anything to protect her. Yoon Ji Hoo - V A member of the F4 and the grandson of a former president of Korea. He has a driving phobia after being involved in a car accident that killed his parents and left him the only survivor. He is initially in love with his childhood friend Seo-hyun, who helped him overcome his social anxiety. Calm and gentle, his musical talent catches Jan-di's attention and she begins to develop feelings for him. So Yi Jung - Jungkook A member of the F4 and a skilled potter. His family owns the country's biggest art museum. After losing his first love to his brother, he becomes a Casanova. He eventually changes his playboy ways when he realizes that he likes Ga-eul. Song Woo Bin A member of the F4, his family runs the country's largest construction company, which Woo-bin later admits has strong connections to organized crime. However, he has excellent business sense and is very charismatic. He's a super nice guy that happens to be a gangster lol and of course RM, Jin, and Jimin are the dad, mom, and little brother :) How would you cast BOF?
bestest korean kisses
finally, i could post this video at last... you don't know how many times i've tried uploading this on youtube and failed.. i've made this vid one whole day... editing, trimming, looking up the story summaries... gave me a big headache but it didn't stop me from finishing this. i've accumulated kiss vids that to me has an awesome kiss and i came up with this one... @neaa...from 19:29 minutes, i've cut it down to 14:42, so it won't exceed the 15 min.. default for uploading on youtube, this is for you...lol here are the details:(d for drama/m for movie) the best of the best korean kisses... 1. goong yoo and yoon eun hae (coffee prince) d 2. joo ji hoon and yoon eun hae (goong) d 3. joo ji hoon and shin min ah (the naked kitchen) m 4. bi rain and shin min ah (a love to kill) d 5. bi rain and im so jung (i'm a cyborg but that's okay) m 6. goong yoo and kim sun ah (she's on duty) m 7. bae yong jun and son hye jin (april snow) m 8. song seung hun and kim tae hee (my princess) d 9. lee min ho and son hye jin (personal taste) d 10. lee min ho and park min young (city hunter) d 11. park si hoo and kim so yeon (prosecutor princess) d 12. park si hoo and kim nam joo (queen of reversal) d 13. jung il woo and lee chung ah (flower boy ramyun shop) d 14. jang geun suk and yoona (love rain) d 15. jang geun suk and moon geun young (mary stayed out all night) d 16. song joong ki and moon chae won (nice guy/innocent man) d 17. song joong ki and lee seong min (five senses of eros) m 18. ji hyun woo and yoo in na (queen in hyun's man) d 19. jung yoo mi and lee jin wook (i need romance 2) d -neaa reminded me of reply 1997's kiss on the stairs.. forgot about that.. that was great too.. -and i've included jang geun suk's kisses here with yoona and moon geun young coz i think that he is such a great kisser, it's just so sad that he wasn't given a leading lady that matches his kissing prowess...^^
Vingle love 4 Cmtys!
It’s the last card of the Series and time to highlight the Top communities! You know the ones, In the Thousands that have been in the care of so many amazing people throughout the years! This is a card to show appreciation to the Presidents currently still bringing life and happiness into communities!  To highlight 2, The Kpop cmty and The BTS cmty are highly active and has so many cards! The Presidents @Halsyeon and @Yugykookie along with their Editors have done stupendous work with managing the cmty’s that get so many cards!      ▪☆▪☆▪☆▪☆▪☆▪☆▪☆▪ There are 13 Cmty’s being mentioned in this card! Also to include a couple extra high cmtys. KDrama, Quotes, & Travel.  may not be in the Music genre but wanted to include them because well I do like to keep an eye on the cmty’s that interlock with the kpop world, PLUS KDRAMA lol.           ●☆●☆●☆●☆●☆●☆● For some of these cmty’s They are recently coming up or just came up to term So Presidents named are who has Monitored over the last couple months and the changes presented are in their time frame!!! Thank you to all the Presidents for doing such amazing work! Top Communities! 13. Its time to see the tracking. How many new members have these cmtys gotten since the begining of Feb! ▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪▪ VIXX 》     Cmty Had 11.4k members With the President being @MaeLyn      It is now currently at 11.8k members!    Thats fantastic! T.O.P 》   Cmty Had 12.7k members With the President being @Starbell808    It is now currently at 12.9k        100 BTS 》    Cmty Had 14.4k members With the President being @Yugykookie It was at 14.5 on feb 18th  It is now currently at 15.3k    .9k- 900 new members!! Great Job in your cmty girl!! G-Dragon  》   Cmty Had 15.5k members With the President being @BBxGD. It is now currently at    15.7k    .2k= 200 Shinee 》   Cmty Had 16.8k members With the President being @VixenViVi    It is now currently at 17k That is .2k-200 new members! Super Junior  》   Cmty Had 18.9k members With the President being @QueenPandaBunny It is now currently at 19.2k    .3k=300 EXO  》   Cmty Had 20.7k members With the President being @MelissaGarza It is now currently at 21.2k    .4k = 400 new members! AsianMale Stars. 》 Cmty Had 36.7k members With the President being @BBxGD It is now currently at    36.9k    .2k-200 Koreanstars. 》 64.7k members With the President being @DefSoul This is a new one I saw so Im sorry It doesnt have a beginning number. Kpop  》 Cmty Had 113.2k members With the President being @Halsyeon   114.7k    members currently. There are 1500 new members! Its a popping! K-Dramas   》  Cmty Had 139.3k members With the President being @SweetDuella It is now currently at 140k    .7k= 700 Quotes 》  Cmty Had 151.6k members With the President being @ jazminramirez9    It is now currently at 152.7k     with 1.1k- 1100 new members! Travel  》  Cmty Had 156.1k members With the President being @ Carcake It is now currently at 157k    .9k= 900 fam tag! new updated list!  @SugaKookieV @StefaniTre  @SimplyAwkward @Starbell808 @SerenaArthurs @Sugasadamsapple @BabydollBre  @WinKonVIP    @Taekookimonster  @ESwee @Just2BLoved  @QueenPandaBunny   @Yugykookie97 @kpopandkimchi  @VKookie47 @MelissaGarza  @VeronicaArtino  @tinafalcon22 @tigerlily84 @Taekookimonster   @JaxomB  @divanicola05  @ynsamgwlk @rchacon19 @cns1391  @PolarStarr  @rocklvr @BTSARMYBOI @QueenyCrossGene @BTSMicdrop