5,000+ Views

What the Fandom: What is a headcanon?

And do I want one?

The earliest use of the term headcanon was 2007, but it became popular in 2010. Fanlore defines a headcanon as "a fan's personal, idiosyncratic interpretation of canon, such as the backstory of a character, or the nature of relationships between characters."

Still confused?

"Canon" is considered the "text" of a book, movie, or tv series. So in Pride and Prejudice Elizabeth and Darcy end up together: that's what happens in the book, so it's canon. But the book ends before we see their wedding. If you think that Elizabeth would be a total Bridezilla, that's your personal headcanon. The book doesn't demonstrate this, but you're entitled to what you imagine about the characters.

Who shot first: Han or Greedo?

Sometimes headcanons arise because of inconsistencies in storytelling (the Star Wars re-release caused confusion among fan communities, because the new Cantina Scene appeared to be different from the original). Some headcanons reimagine characters as LGBT, because fans feel that kind of diversity is too scarce. Often, fans do this without realizing: they make assumptions about the characters or circumstances that, while based on the canon, are not actually textual interpretations.

Headcanon vs. Canon vs. Fanon

So we know that a headcanon is an individual experience, an idea or conviction you might have about a piece of media. This can include or be inspired by subtext, or it can be a completely separate conclusion drawn from personal opinions or desires.
Canon is literally what the original media says or purports to be. While one could argue that sometimes subtext is intentional and part of canon, overall canon is understood to be speculation-free. It's literally what happened on screen.

So what the heck is fanon?

Fanon is a communal headcanon, that a group or groups of fans have accepted, either intentionally or through osmosis. A popular headcanon among the Sherlock community is that John Watson always makes the tea. This is actually so well-recognized that fans often either forget or don't know that this is entirely false: in the show, the only character seen making tea is Sherlock (though Mrs. Hudson is often providing it, she never makes it on screen).
[Text: i head canon human fluttershy as an Indian or Pjilippina trans girl who is lesbian. i also head canon rainbow dash as a mixed black-latina demi-girl who identifies as lesbian. they're totally dating. :D]

Why is this a thing?

Fans have had headcanons since there was media to enjoy. I'm talking ancient Greek disagreements over whether Patroclus and Achilles were lovers, and if so: who bottomed? (Yeah, those arguments are as old as time). Because being a fan is such a personal experience, our minds tend to get very focused on the media we love. Headcanons are often a creative outlet for us; they allow us to continue enjoying the story even though we're not currently experiencing it.
Here are a few of my favorite headcanons, organized by fandom:
Harry Potter
Harry is going to be really great dad, the kind with pockets full of chocolate Draco Malfoy gets REALLY into Muggle stuff after the war Hermione Granger keeps her maiden name when she gets married
Bruce Banner is an environmental activist Sam Wilson is a total foodie Tony Stark funds nonprofits for women in STEM
Irene Adler still texts Sherlock, he just remembers to put his phone on silent now Anthea is actually the one running the government Sherlock still sneaks cigarettes
Fans share their headcanons through blogs, fanfiction, and art. They use headcanons to make fan spaces more diverse and welcoming, to build community, and to keep creating content even though the original media has been cancelled or is on hiatus. Obviously, some fans keep their headcanons to themselves (you probably have some of your own that you might not have realized until now). Headcanons aren't all that strange- the term may be new, but the phenomenon is centuries old. They're a way of experiencing media.
@shannonl5 sorry didn't mean to touch a nerve. and it was awesome. my Alice rped with my online friends Castiel. if I can dig up our old rps I will private message you them
@LadyExperiment true, it's okay, and I understand being very passionate about the things you love (haha that's me all over). I think in part it was the 'not a true fan thing', I've heard that a lot at some (granted, poorly run) conventions and it's usually something people say to girls because they liked the movies before they read the comics or something, so it struck a bit of a raw nerve with me. RE x Supernatural actually sounds like an awesome crossover!
@shannonl5 True but I was just voicing my opinion. I get passionate and headstrong about defending the things I like. No offense @buddyesd. But just give it a try okay? open your mind to a whole new part of the series that you love. as I said before the movies are alternate universe so hence they are not cannon with the games. Alice is pretty badass. I have been rping as her for years on and some of the best rps I have had is mixing the movies into the games. heck I have even done a resident evil movie crossover rp with the show Supernatural
@LadyExperiment woah, I think it's ok to disagree about something like this. There's no need to tell someone they're not a true fan. I get that it's really important to you and it's ok to defend something you love (especially since the movies brought you to the games, that's an awesome thing) but we all like what we like, and dislike what we dislike.
@shannonl5 they do please fans with the CGI movies. just because he is butt hurt that his favorite character became a supportive role doesn't take away from the movie. trust me I know. I am a fan of the Devil May Cry games and I was excited to hear that they were making a new game only to rage when I realized that they were making a reboot game. and that everything in it had nothing to do with the other games. well I finally played a bit of it on my boyfriends Xbox 360 and then the next day I went out and bought a new copy. yes I am sad that there most likely will be no more orginal Dante games with the characters we all know and love but I also love the new game enough that I can't wait for them to make another game. I beat the game in a day, rushing through it to complete it because I wanted to know what happened next. so if @buddyesd is to stubborn to even give the RE movies a chance because they don't parallel the games then he isn't a true fan of the series.
Cards you may also be interested in
5 Struggles Every Shipper Has
Whatever your fandom, the struggle is real. We all know these feels. We might fight in ship wars against each other, we might accidentally insult someone's OTP or be totally confused by each others' obsessions... But at the end of the day fans need to stick together. Because if you ship, eventually you're going to run into these problems. And you'll need someone to commiserate with. 1. You can never find that perfect fic Whether your OTP is the current fandom favorite or an obscure couple only five other people have ever heard of, it can feel like an impossible task to find the *perfect* fic. Sure, you'll read (and love) yet ANOTHER coffee shop au full of tropes you know like the back of your hand, but you'll be craving something more for the rest of your shipper life. And don't even talk to be about that unfinished WIP I've been checking for the past three years. 2. Your Ship > Your Sleep Schedule When is the last time you went to bed instead of staying up late reading fanfiction? Does it feel like never? Because it feels like never to me. You forgo silly mortal needs like sleep for more important things like digging up more images of your OTP, beta-ing just one more chapter, or rolling around in feels. And speaking of feels... 3. EVERYTHING gives you feels Every song on the radio? Written for your OTP. Every time you order coffee? You get the same order as your favorite character. Literally everything anyone says? Your shipper brain will find a way to react to it and you will be overwhelmed by feels. It's a constant barrage and there is no escape. 4. The world doesn't get you And vise-versa. Shippers tend to create our own special language, and we start to speak it exclusively. I can absolutely tell you what "ao3 mcu a:aou abo bdsm ot3 hs au pwp" means, but I have no idea what the Pythagorean theorem is. Look at our lives, look at our choices. (And before you ask, you know you'd read that fic, don't lie). 5. You've got a family for life The shipper family is one of the most welcoming, creative, beautiful groups of people I've ever encountered. There's so much love in this community. We scream and cry and FEEL like the world is ending... and we're all in it together. Whatever your ship, you're always welcome among us. You've always got a home. ... there's nothing like a weird Harry Potter gif to break up the feels parade. Let's show some pride shippers! Anime, Superwholock, HP, Trek, Marvel... How much do you relate to this?