jeff4122
1,000+ Views

I Can't Believe It's Not ____!: Songs you didn't know were covers

Full disclosure: Neither butter nor its evil counterpart, I Can't Believe It's Not Butter!, have really anything to do with the rest of this card at all. But the name is just so damn catchy and malleable, so, forgive me.
Moving on, I'm here to give some love to the original composers and performers of songs that you may not know deserve credit. Sometimes, a song gets buried for years, only to be picked up by a totally different artist (often in a different genre and style), and it's the second version that blows up. In lots of these cases, there is little mention of the original.
Let's change that.

I Can't Believe It's Not LED ZEPPELIN!

Song: "Dazed and Confused" (1969)
Original: Jake Holmes (1967)
Eerily enough, Jake Holmes actually has some real Robert Plant qualities to his voice. Or maybe Plant ripped his vocal style off of Holmes just like he did one of his best songs. I don't know. Is nothing sacred?

I Can't Believe It's Not AMY WINEHOUSE!

Song: "Valerie" (2007)
Original: The Zutons (2006)
The Zutons are kind of a guilty pleasure of mine. They're a not-very-good mid-2000s Brit rock group, but something about the lead singer's voice is really appealing to me. Amy's version is damn-near perfect and is the basis of every A Capella group's top hit, but it wouldn't have been possible without The Zutons. Which is not something that you can say for many things in this world.

I Can't Believe It's Not ARETHA FRANKLIN!

Song: "Respect" (1967)
Original: Otis Redding (1965)
Ok, this one is legitimately surprising. I've heard the Otis version a million times and I didn't know that it was his song until recently. The two versions are really, really different, and each is awesome in its own right. It's hard to go wrong with Otis or Aretha. Everyone wins.

I Can't Believe It's Not THE BEATLES!

Song: "Twist and Shout" (1963)
Original: The Isley Brothers (1962)
The Isley Brothers didn't actually write this song - Phil Medley and Bert Burns did - but they were the first to chart the song, before The Beatles did a year later.
Fun fact: The Beatles recorded Please Please Me, the record that contains this hit, in just 10 hours. Their producer knew that "Twist and Shout" would totally ruin John Lennon's voice because of its demanding style, so he saved it for last, with just 15 minutes of scheduled recording time left. Indeed, it totally blew out Lennon's voice, and, while the producer wanted to do a second take, Lennon just couldn't manage it. Ended up fine, if you ask me.

I Can't Believe It's Not ELVIS PRESLEY!

Song: "Hound Dog" (1956)
Original: Big Mama Thornton (1952)
Oh man! OH MAN! Who is Big Mama Thornton, and where has she been? This woman is a force! She also recorded "Ball n' Chain" before Janis Joplin made it a hit. Give the lady some love! This version is fucking awesome!
But, yeah, Elvis's is better. Sorry Big Mama.
Which one surprises you the most?

Do you like the originals better, or the more popular covers?

Music community folks:

Reveal yourselves!

6 Comments
Suggested
Recent
Whoa! Great and informative article! Thanks!
@jeff4122 I am extremely jealous of your proximity to Chuck Berry. Definitely check out Rosetta Tharpe, she has a lot of raw passion in her music. It's cool to see how she influenced the King!
@shannonl5 chuck berry still plays once a month at a bar near my school. I haven't been yet but really need to make that happen because....well... he's old. and I don't know Rosetta Tharpe! will investigate
The last three actually shocked me!! Elvis, the Beatles, Aretha... it's hard to outdo those dudes. But I think the originals definitely deserve a bit more credit ;D
Oh wow I had no idea about any of these! The Otis Redding one surprised me the most I think. Lately I've been listening to a lot of Chuck Berry and Rosetta Tharpe because they were such a huge influence on Elvis. Clearly I need to investigate even more!
Cards you may also be interested in
6 John Lennon Quotes To Honor A True Revolutionary
Today marks the day that legendary John Lennon was murdered and @tessstevens wrote an amazing card honoring him that you can read here! John Lennon has been a staple in my house since I can remember. In fact, my Dad told me that on the day Lennon died he cried hysterically and since then has hated the book Catcher In The Rye (which was held by the shooter). It was very awkward when I had to read it in high school. But in honor of John Lennon, here are some of his most famous (yet still amazingly revenant) quotes that will live in infamy. This is my all time favorite quote. Because it really shouldn't matter what you are doing or where you are in life. As long as you are happy, then everything really is okay. "All you need is love" right? It might not work out, it might not be your only love, and it might not be the right love, but at any point in your life love is always a blessing. Speaking of love, they only way to find perfect, lasting love is to first find a way to be happy by yourself. Looking for happiness in another person will only leave you feeling empty. Bombs, beheadings, and blood are scattered across the screens. We look refugees fleeing war in the face and turn our backs. Yet god forbid someone posts a nipple on social media. Thank you John Lennon, for validating my existence and reminding everyone that being weird is what makes you special. And the words that will get me through any hard time, if I am not happy, it is not the end.
How to Look Like Stevie Nicks
Whether you love Stevie's solo stuff or are a die-hard Fleetwood Mac fan, you can't deny that the songbird had some killer style back in the day. From her peasant-princess 70's looks to her amped-up 80's style, I'm taking you through Stevie Nicks' style. (Special shout-out to @allischaaff for reminding me how inspirational Ms. Nicks' fashion has been!) 70's In the 1970's, Fleetwood Mac was fresh on the music scene, and Stevie Nicks was the gorgeous lead singer that had an understated bohemian fashion sense envied by all. Her half-up, half-down blonde hairstyle was embellished with eyebrow skimming bangs. She wore plenty of trends of the seventies from peasant blouses to bell-bottoms, but she kept them sultry and simple, often in black, white, or cream. 70's Stevie was not shy of accessorizing, however, and she layered on necklaces and chains as embellishment to her simple dresses and tops. A chain or two would add some subtle glamour to an otherwise breezy and lightweight bohemian look. These aviator sunglasses were also a common look, coyly tucked under her signature bangs. She often wore a kimono, scarf, or shawl draped over her arms for some stylish coverage. 70's For the cameras, Ms. Nicks hammed up her seventies style with brooches, halters, and her flippy, flippy hair. The flared jeans and platform heel combo was then and is now especially cool and relaxed looking, without seeming costumey. 80's ...and then came the 1980's, and our beloved bohemian goddess went through a bit of a transformation. If this is the look you're after, take a comb to your hair, and just start teasing. Gone is Stevie's fresh face, to be replaced with a bright lip and swept-on blush. There's something to say for Stevie's look in the 80's. Perhaps it was over-the-top and bolder than her demure 70's style, but she was also coming into her own and recording solo music at the time, which turned out to be a big success. Her signature pout stayed the same all along, she just added more or less to emphasize those blonde longs and her petite frame. 80's Stevie went in the glam route in the 80's, but merged the boldness of glitter and sequins with a witchy darkness that seperated her from cutsier girl groups of the decade. If you aren't afraid to try some big hair and sparkle, avoid color and drape yourself in feathers and sequins in black for the Stevie effect. "Stand Back" shows more 80's influence than her softer work (like Landslide) with Fleetwood Mac, but she also develops a more nuanced sound that sets her apart from 80's pop, and her dark and enchanting style shows this. Stevie Nicks has been aptly named the fairy godmother of rock. Throw on some layered necklaces and black sequins, and tease up your hair to channel your inner Stevie and feel the girl power course through your veins.
Mac Sabbath: The McDonald's Metal Band Of Your Nightmares
Just when you thought Ronald McDonald was as scary as clowns got, in comes Ronald Osbourne. From the poofy red wig and the yellow gloves, he's got all the fast food joint's iconic colors in place; however, something sinister boils beneath the surface. This is Mac Sabbath, a Black Sabbath cover band that combines all things Prince of Darkness with ketchup, mayo, and the occasional sweet and sour dipping sauce. And in this gig, Ronald Osbourne is the fast food world's Prince of Darkness equivalent. Needless to say, you should be scared. Very scared. And instead of 'Iron Man', their signature song is 'Frying Pan', which equal parts mocks the quality of fast food and the health of the people who eat it a little too frequently. Oh, and you've got to see Ronald's bandmates. There's Slayer MacCheeze, Grimalice, and Catburglar, who looks a whole lot like Peter Criss from the original KISS line-up. And just like the original Black Sabbath, Ronald and the crew are just as notorious for their extreme stage antics. After attending their concert last summer, music journalist Jake Manson observed a move pulled right out of the Ozzy Osbourne handbook: "The highlight came when Ronald reached into his takeout bag, pulled out a hamburger with bat wings, and took a massive bite out of it." So what do you guys think about Mac Sabbath? Have you seen any clown rock this hard? Let me know if you'd be down to see Mac Sabbath live in concert in the comments below, and for more WTF news, follow my WTF Street Journal collection.
What made the '80s so great?
From the iconic music to eye-catching fashion, 1980-1989 was a simpler yet incredibly memorable time for many. There were plenty of great things that came from the 80's, but I will choose two things I enjoyed the most: 1-Saved By The Bell. I know it seems like just yesterday that the show was in it's prime, but that show has been around for 25 plus years. The first season let loose in 1989. While I was in college, this was one of my favorite shows to watch in between classes. 2-Nintendo - I mean, where do I start on this system? They created countless games that changed the video game console world. The Game Boy also was invented in the 80's which set the tone for the constant virtual gaming experience we enjoy today. Earlier today the hashtag #WhatMadeThe80sSoGreat started trending, so my fellow Vinglers, share a couple things from the 80's that you still enjoy today! @Inaritricx @Taijiotter @AimeeH @XergaB20 @JustinaNguyen @RainaC3 @bnrenchilada @destiny1419 @arnelli @Luci546 @Ash2424701 @GingerMJones @zwdodds @LenaBlackRose @misssukyi @TerraToyaSi @kneelb4zod @BrookeStam @RachelParker @JaxomB @ultraninja10 @reyestiny93 @MattK95 @MajahnNelson @petname83 @BluBear07 @melifluosmelodi @ZoilaObregon @GossamoKewen95 @TracyLynnn @TiffanyWallace @VixenViVi @DenieceSuit @ButterflyBlu @CelinaGonzalez @MaighdlinS @maddiemoozer @VeronicaArtino @iixel @TomHawthorne @DominiqueThomas @ElizabethT @RiggaFoster @AluSparklez @kvnguyen @chris98vamg @WiviDemol @animechild51 @2Distracted @cthulu @jazziejazz @JessicaChaney @shantalcamara @J1mbleJ4mz @Beeplzzz @carmaa10 @MayraYanez @Kamiamon @HeatherWright @MischiefK1ng @SeoInHan @ShonA @KennyMcCormick @MooshieBay @IMNII @Ikpoper @humairaa @merryjayne13 @zoemvillarreal @lilleonz @ChristinaOMalle @AllieGrabowski @baileykayleen @KarleyFrance @Ticasensei @EasternShell @musicundefined9 @peahyr @TerrecaRiley @MoisEsGaray @atmi @AlidaGarman @sanRico @orenshani7 @jannatd93 @ReadAnimateSwim @Astrohelix @dimplequeen @ChildofSparda13 @grapetoes2000 @sarahpjane @LittleHorn @justinasarmento @deilig @GalaxyTacoCat @amobigbang @LAVONYORK @Jason41 @kpopdeluxegirl @BlackDragon88 @Bobs @paularasnick @Animaniafreak @YumiMiyazaki @Patmanmeow @MarvelTrashcan @kawaiiporpoise @Xiuyeolhyun @MaggieHolm @xDaisyDaysx @yaakattackk @Starbell808 @KyleBerke @fatimajj23 @GabrielMarques @Alletaire @kkimberlyy @Priscillasdoor @chrisg3584 @brandontearss @bradleygialamas @justme29 @buddyesd @changoleon @Sara3 @felicityautumn @ssora @MorghanPorter @IzamarPalomo @realjoy @Heartofgold35 @mscocoasupreme @MyFunkySpell @ChakiahWallace @Krystalstar22 @KarlythePanda66 @JoeyNelson @TonyLepera @dianes6711 @Aripendragon @MichelleHolly @AviannaLin @seouls @AustinThurston @Sammyjuicoooo @divanicola05 @RavenQueen0810 @captpeter @Kourtland @Tsukasakrdcd @MistyTaylorByrd @MariPili @TylerCassalata @SarahRegulski @Melodicballoon @heyitskat