The Mets have a decision on their hands.
With veteran left fielder Michael Cuddyer set to return from a DL stint today, the roster is going to see a shake-up.
Even though Cuddyer has been really disappointing for most of the season, he's an important veteran player and he deserves to be on the 25-man roster, no question about it.
But, as one comes, another goes. Who's it going to be?
There are really only two legitimate options: Left fielder and rookie future-star Michael Conforto, or utility man Eric Campbell.
The case for keeping Campbell
Is Campbell great? No. But he's a known commodity - if you can call a lifetime .225 hitter (batting just .179) on the season a 'commodity' at all. He can play several positions - third base, second base, outfield. And, he's actually come up with a few pretty major hits this season despite his low average. He can play multiple positions (Conforto is really a true left fielder) and is a right-handed hitter, something the Mets have use for.
The main upside for keeping Campbell on the roster is what it means for Conforto. As it stands, he doesn't play every day. And when Cuddyer comes back, his playing time will only go down. He's a young player with tons of potential, and it's dangerous to have a player like that in the lineup only once or twice a week. Many people would much rather see him playing every day in Triple-A so he can be ready to stand out next season.
The case for keeping Conforto
He's better than Campbell. Hands down. End of story.
I'm keeping Campbell and sending Conforto down.
I know Campbell is terrible, and I'm as sick of seeing him play as the next guy. But he's a righty, and keeping Conforto on the team to play only once or twice a week could really hurt his development. Sandy Alderson has said that he's focusing on this season, not developing for next, and I respect that - but Conforto is going to be a big deal in a few years, and I don't want to mess with that. Plus, David Wright is looking like he'll return sooner rather than later, and with his return, Campbell will surely be the guy to go.